Saltar al contenido
domingo, 22 de noviembre de 2026

Tribuna Atlántica

Pensamiento contemporáneo

Derecho Digital e IA

Where Are Law and Artificial Intelligence Heading?

Artificial intelligence is no longer merely a technology that law seeks to regulate. As AI systems increasingly participate in decision-making and the exercise of institutional power, they are transforming the foundations of legal authority, accountability, and legitimacy. This article examines how the future of law depends not only on regulating AI, but on governing the power exercised through it.

University Lecturer | Legal Consultant | Researcher in Digital Law, Intellectual Property and Emerging Technologies
Irán9 min de lectura

Compartir este artículo

Where Are Law and Artificial Intelligence Heading?
From Technology Regulation to the Transformation of the Nature and Authority of Law

Seyed Mohammad Hosseini

Artificial intelligence is no longer merely a technology that legal systems can manage through the adoption of a few laws, the imposition of restrictions, or the establishment of liability rules. It is increasingly entering areas that have traditionally fallen within the domain of human decision-making, judgment, and authority. From economic and commercial activities to public administration, the judicial system, and the provision of legal services, intelligent systems are changing how decisions are formed and implemented.

In these circumstances, the fundamental question is no longer simply how law should regulate artificial intelligence. Rather, it is necessary to ask how artificial intelligence itself will transform law, legal institutions, and the exercise of legal authority.

The central argument of this article is that the future relationship between law and artificial intelligence cannot be analysed solely within the framework of technology regulation. Artificial intelligence is moving beyond its role as an auxiliary tool and is becoming part of the infrastructure through which decisions are made and power is exercised. This transformation presents legal systems with a deeper challenge: how can they preserve legitimate authority, accountability, and effective protection of individual rights when an increasing number of decisions are shaped through intelligent systems?

From Intelligent Tools to Agents of Action

During the early stages of generative AI development, legal debates largely focused on issues such as intellectual property infringement, personal data protection, algorithmic discrimination, and liability arising from inaccurate outputs. However, technological development has not stopped at this stage. Agentic AI systems are now capable of planning towards specific objectives, using digital tools, and carrying out sequences of actions with minimal human intervention.

From a legal perspective, there is a fundamental difference between a system that provides recommendations concerning the conclusion of a contract and one that, with access to commercial infrastructure, places orders or executes transactions within the scope of delegated authority. In the latter case, the issue is no longer limited to the accuracy of an output or the quality of a response. Questions arise concerning the scope of authority, attribution of conduct, the validity of obligations, and liability for actions performed by the system.

This development raises new questions for traditional concepts of both private and public law. Does a system’s technical ability to perform a particular action automatically mean that it possesses the legal authority to do so? How should the scope of authority delegated to an AI agent be defined? Which person or institution should bear responsibility for its actions?

It seems likely that, in the coming years, law will have to move beyond its exclusive focus on controlling AI outputs and address the regulation of actions, delegated powers, and the legal consequences arising from the operation of intelligent systems.

AI Governance: Beyond the Adoption of Legislation

In recent years, various legal systems have sought to address the risks associated with artificial intelligence through the development of regulatory frameworks and legislative instruments. The European Union’s Artificial Intelligence Act (EU AI Act) is an important example of this approach. Through risk classification and the establishment of obligations for different actors, it provides a legal framework for the development and use of this technology.

Nevertheless, the adoption of legislation alone does not guarantee effective governance. Implementing complex technology regulations requires institutions equipped with specialised knowledge, qualified personnel, sufficient resources, access to relevant information, and the capacity for continuous oversight. Even the most carefully drafted legal rules may become ineffective obligations in the absence of adequate enforcement capacity.

From this perspective, a distinction must be drawn between regulation and governance. Regulation primarily focuses on establishing rules and defining legal requirements. Governance, however, encompasses not only rules but also decision-making structures, the allocation of responsibilities, oversight, assessment, stakeholder participation, and accountability mechanisms.

Gillian Hadfield’s analysis of legal infrastructure for transformative AI governance also highlights this necessity. The challenge is not merely to design legal restrictions; it is equally important to establish the legal and institutional infrastructure required to identify, supervise, and manage advanced technologies.

Accordingly, the future of AI governance will depend less on the number of laws enacted or the severity of sanctions imposed than on the capacity of legal systems to understand technological developments and effectively implement their rules.

Artificial Intelligence Within the Legal System

One of the most significant developments ahead is the integration of artificial intelligence into the internal processes of legal systems. AI is no longer merely a subject of legislation; it can also play a role in analysing judicial documents, identifying relationships between legal rules, classifying legal arguments, and supporting judicial and administrative decision-making.

Research published in the fields of artificial intelligence and law indicates that large language models have the capacity to analyse certain complex features of legal reasoning. Studies on the use of AI within judicial institutions have also examined its application in information management, case organisation, and processes related to legal decision-making.

However, a distinction must be maintained between technological support for decision-making and the transfer of decision-making authority itself. Judicial and administrative decisions are not, in many cases, merely the product of data processing. They also require legal interpretation, contextual assessment, respect for fundamental rights, and the exercise of legally conferred powers.

This distinction is particularly important. If artificial intelligence begins to influence the stages of analysis, recommendation, and even the formation of legal decisions, it may affect the information considered by decision-makers, the options available to them, and ultimately the outcomes they reach. In such circumstances, technology is no longer merely an instrument for implementing law; it becomes one of the factors shaping the internal operation of the legal system.

Legal Authority and Legitimacy in the Age of Algorithmic Decisions

One of the fundamental risks associated with the development of artificial intelligence is the confusion of technical performance with legal legitimacy. A system may be capable of reviewing thousands of cases in a short period or generating recommendations with a high level of statistical accuracy. But is such performance, by itself, sufficient to justify the legal acceptance of its decisions?

Within a legal system, the outcome of a decision is not the only relevant criterion. The competence of the decision-making authority, the possibility of understanding the reasons behind a decision, the right to challenge it, and the availability of review mechanisms are equally important.

For example, if an AI system within a public institution rejects an application for a legally available service, the affected individual should be able to understand the factors that influenced the decision, challenge its reasoning, and identify the authority responsible for reviewing the objection.

A mere reference to an algorithmic output cannot replace the legal justification of a decision or the accountability of the authority responsible for making it. For this reason, the evaluation of AI systems must go beyond technical accuracy and also consider the legitimacy of their use, the possibility of oversight, and the ability to challenge decisions.

In this context, the issue of legal authority becomes increasingly significant. Legal authority is not merely the ability to make or implement a decision. It requires a legal basis, valid competence, and the possibility of holding the responsible authority accountable. If parts of the decision-making process become dependent on algorithmic infrastructure, it must remain clear where final authority lies and how legal responsibility is exercised.

Accordingly, satisfactory technical performance is an important condition for the use of artificial intelligence, but it does not, in itself, establish legal legitimacy.

Global Governance: Between International Cooperation and Regulatory Competition

The cross-border nature of artificial intelligence limits the ability of national legal systems to exercise complete control over it. Models, data, computing infrastructure, and service providers may be located in different jurisdictions, while the consequences of a system’s operation may affect several countries simultaneously.

The OECD AI Principles and the Council of Europe Framework Convention on Artificial Intelligence and Human Rights, Democracy and the Rule of Law are examples of efforts to establish common foundations for the governance of this technology. Nevertheless, differences between legal systems, economic priorities, and security considerations make the emergence of a fully unified global legal framework unlikely in the near future.

A more plausible path appears to be the development of mechanisms for cooperation, coordination, and interoperability among different regulatory frameworks. Under these circumstances, competition between countries will not be limited to the development of the most advanced AI models. Their ability to establish enforceable rules, build public trust, and ensure effective protection of individual rights will also become increasingly important.

The Future of the Legal Profession and Human Capacity

Developments in artificial intelligence will also transform the professional activities of legal practitioners. Legal research, document review, information extraction, contract drafting, and preliminary case analysis are among the tasks that intelligent systems can help perform more efficiently.

However, legal practice is not limited to information processing. Assessing a client’s interests, identifying risks under uncertain circumstances, interpreting rules in context, negotiating, and accepting professional responsibility continue to require human judgment and supervision.

Consequently, the principal transformation in the legal profession is unlikely to be the complete elimination of human professionals. Rather, it will involve the redistribution of tasks and a change in the nature of the skills required. Understanding technology, evaluating intelligent outputs, managing risk, and becoming familiar with digital governance principles will increasingly form part of the professional competence of legal practitioners.

At the same time, excessive reliance on AI outputs may weaken independent analytical capacity and legal reasoning skills. The use of technology must therefore be accompanied by the preservation of professional responsibility, confidentiality, and meaningful human oversight.

Conclusion: The Central Challenge Is the Governance of Power

The developments discussed above demonstrate that the future relationship between law and artificial intelligence cannot be reduced to the adoption of new legislation or the replacement of human professions by technology. The more fundamental issue is the changing position of artificial intelligence within the structures through which decisions are made and power is exercised.

Artificial intelligence initially entered different sectors as a tool for performing human tasks. It subsequently became an independent subject of regulation. It is now entering the very processes through which legal decisions are formed and implemented.

This transformation turns the relationship between law and artificial intelligence from a one-directional relationship into a reciprocal one. Law must govern the development and use of technology, but it must also reconsider the capacity of its institutions and traditional concepts to respond to emerging realities.

Ultimately, the central question for the future of law and artificial intelligence is not which system performs more accurately. It is this: when artificial intelligence becomes involved in decision-making and the exercise of power, who holds the authority, who is accountable, and how can individuals affected by these decisions defend their rights?

A desirable future will emerge when technological development is accompanied by legitimate legal authority, institutional accountability, and effective protection of individual rights. Technology may expand the capacity for decision-making, but determining the limits, foundations of legitimacy, and responsibility associated with the exercise of that capacity will remain a legal and institutional matter.

Documentación del artículo

1 documento. Cada uno se abre en una pestaña aparte, para leerlo o descargarlo, sin salir del artículo.

También en Derecho Digital e IA

Ver la sección →